Take the A Train

form & repertoire 3 #jazz-theory#form-and-repertoire

Billy Strayhorn’s “Take the A Train” is the tune where swing-era clarity meets a single, perfectly placed harmonic surprise. Everything about it is legible enough for a big band to sight-read at a dance, yet the chord in bar 3 of every A section — a chromatic dominant with no diatonic business being there — is sophisticated enough that bebop players adopted it as a workout. It became Duke Ellington’s theme song, and for good reason: it teaches AABA Form, Secondary Dominants, and a taste of Lydian Dominant color in one tight 32 bars.

The form: AABA with a real modulation, not a detour

The tune is a classic 32-bar AABA Form — three 8-bar A sections bookending an 8-bar bridge, each section its own self-contained musical thought. What makes the bridge worth studying is that it doesn’t just touch the IV chord in passing; it sets up F major as a genuine second key center for four full bars before working its way back, a clean example of the bridge’s structural job of providing real harmonic contrast before the form resolves home. Because the harmonic rhythm is slow and the changes are unambiguous, the tune became a favorite jam-session vehicle precisely because it lets soloists focus on melodic line rather than untangling the chords — see Jazz Standards as Vehicles.

The A section: a plain vamp interrupted by a chromatic dominant

In C major, the A section spends its first two bars sitting on the tonic, then throws a curveball:

  • Bar 1: C6
  • Bar 2: C6
  • Bar 3: D7(♯11)
  • Bar 4: D7
  • Bar 5: Dm7
  • Bar 6: G7
  • Bar 7: C6
  • Bar 8: C6

That D7 in bars 3–4 is the whole lesson. Diatonically, C major has no D7 chord at all — the ii chord should be Dm7. What Strayhorn writes instead is a secondary dominant built on the same root, borrowed from the sound of a V7 of V7 without actually resolving to G — it slides straight into the real Dm7 in bar 5. The ♯11 (G♯ over a D7 chord) is the note that gives it its signature color: raise the 11th of a dominant chord and you get the sound of Lydian Dominant, the same ♯11/♭7 combination that makes a dominant chord feel bright and floating rather than gravitationally pulled toward resolution. In practice, plenty of players simplify the voicing to a plain D7 or D7♭5 — Ray Nance’s original 1941 trumpet solo doesn’t lean on the alteration at all — so treat the ♯11 as an available color, not a rule.

The bridge: a clean trip to F and back

Where the A section stays anchored in C with one chromatic visitor, the bridge genuinely relocates:

  • Bars 1–4: Fmaj7 (four bars planted in the new key, IV of C treated as a real home)
  • Bars 5–6: D7
  • Bar 7: Dm7
  • Bar 8: G7

That D7–Dm7–G7 close is the same secondary-dominant-into-ii–V logic from the A section, now doing double duty as the pivot back to C major for the final A. Because the whole bridge is diatonically simple — no borrowed scales, no altered tensions beyond the same D7 color already heard in the A — it’s an efficient way to teach how a secondary dominant can either color a static tonic (bars 3–4 of the A) or launch a full modulation (bars 5–8 of the bridge), using the identical D7 sonority both times.

Why bebop players kept it in the book

“Take the A Train” survived the transition from The Swing Era to bebop because its form asks nothing extra of the improviser — no dense reharmonization, no odd bar counts — while still rewarding careful listening, which is why it remains a staple for both big-band head arrangements and small-group jam sessions. Strayhorn composed it in 1939 on a napkin, reportedly following directions Ellington gave him for the New York subway; Ellington’s orchestra recorded it in February 1941 and adopted it permanently as the band’s theme.

♫ Listen

  • Duke Ellington Orchestra — “Take the A Train” (RCA Victor, recorded February 15, 1941): the definitive reading — Ray Nance’s trumpet solo became so identified with the tune that later players quoted it outright; listen for how the band’s swing feel rides under the crisp, riff-based head.
  • Ella Fitzgerald with Duke Ellington and His Orchestra — “Take the A Train” (Ella Fitzgerald Sings the Duke Ellington Song Book, Vol. 1, 1957): a vocal reading of the melody against full sax-section voicings, useful for hearing how a singer phrases through the D7♯11 in bar 3 without losing the lyric’s forward motion.

Related: Swing Feel, Secondary Dominants, The Swing Era, Jazz Standards as Vehicles